Publication: ENIGMA OF THE SEPTUAGENARIAN MUREX 150 150 Israel Ziderman


Irving I. Ziderman
  Abstract of lecture presented at the 28th Annual Meeting on Dyes in History and Archaeology, in  Poznan, Poland, on 22nd October 2009
Purple dyes from Mediterranean murex shellfish were among the most precious treasures of antiquity. There were two types. Tyrian purple (biblical argaman) was made from spiny dye-murex (Bolinus brandaris), often in admixture with rockshell (Stramonita haemastoma); chemically, it is 6,6’-dibromoindigotin. Hyacinth purple (biblical tekhelet) had a bluer shade than Tyrian purple, giving violet-blue colours, and was made from banded dye-murex (Hexaplex trunculus); it is a mixture of dyestuffs, largely 6-monobromoindigotin and indigotin.
Amongst the characteristics specified in the Talmud for recognizing the shellfish (Hebrew hilazon) used for dyeingtekhelet, one of the four points listed there has hitherto escaped satisfactory elucidation: it is – ‘ascends (or goes up) once in seventy years’ (Menahot 44a). A literal meaning would imply a life-cycle lasting seventy years; but the Talmud does not state the year from which to reckon the anniversary. In fact, such longevity is unknown in the mollusk world, including H. trunculus. Moreover, there is no historical indication of this periodicity in regard to the ancient hyacinth-purple-dyeing craft. Indeed, it is implausible that, throughout its 3,000 year-long history, such a widespread manufacturing industry was dependant on supply of its essential raw material becoming available just once in seventy years.
Therefore previous authors have been constrained to regard the Talmudic enigma as hyperbole, merely indicating that the creatures reappeared intermittently: so ‘once in seventy years’ may perhaps be just a metaphoric allusion to the renowned infrequency of Halley’s comet. Accordingly, Herzog (1913) rejected H. trunculus as the source of ritual tekhelet because it appeared to lack such rarity. Some alternative Talmudic texts have ‘seven’ instead of ‘seventy’; consequently, Spanier and Ziderman (1982) associated a cycle of seven (months) with the biannual seasons for H. trunculus fishing.
Thus it is not surprising that Maimonides’ authoritative Code of Judaic law (1178) makes no mention of the enigmatic phrase, even though the other three characteristics from the Talmud are duly recorded there (Zizith 2:2). However, the Code does add there a novel fourth characteristic of tekhelet’s shellfish – ‘It is to be found in the Salt (=Mediterranean) Sea’, a phrase hitherto considered to be merely an innovation of Maimonides, it not being taken from the Talmud.
It is now proposed that Maimonides considered the Talmud’s ‘ascends once in seventy years’ to mean that the murex never ascends out of the sea, but is to be found only in the Mediterranean, whence it must necessarily be fished despite the dangers involved.
Talmud: Menahot 44a
Maimonides: Zizit 2:2
This snail [hilazon]:
This snail [hilazon]
1.      its body resembles the sea
1.      is a fish
2.      and its formation resembles a fish
2.      whose coloration resembles
the coloration of the sea
3.      and it ascends* once in 70 years**
3.      and its blood is as black as ink
4.      and with its bloodtekhelet is dyed.
4.      and it is to be found in the Salt Sea.
Therefore its value is expensive.
* “Ascends” – from the sea, since they are fished with nets:
Talmud Shabbat 74b – Hunters of shellfish knot and unknot.
Rashi’s Commentary – Hunters of shellfish, in order to dye the tekhelet with its blood.
Knot and unknot; since all nets are made of multiple knottings … and sometimes cords need to be taken from one net and added to another, unknotting from one and knotting to the other.
** “Once in seventy years” – once in a blue moon
Mishna Makkot 1:10 – A Supreme Court [Sanhedrin] that metes out capital punishment once in seven years is called destructive. Rabbi Elazar son of Azarya says: once in seventy years.

Israel Ziderman

Scientific Director, Tekhelet Foundation
Chairman, Union of Civilian Research Scientists in Israel
Scientific Editor, Yalkut Journal of the Israel Textile & Fashion Association

All stories by : Israel Ziderman